We ordered Theodore Pratt’s Tropical Disturbance long before hurricane season arrived, but as the timing worked out we read it during Dorian, and the news reports reminded us of what the author sometimes didn’t. The main plot device here is a love triangle between a rich clod, a poor everyman, and a beautiful virgin who both of the guys would be better off without. Pratt didn’t intend for the third to be true. He lost his way because of his desire to contrive a specific type of conflict. But the problem is we don’t think a woman who’s dating one man can begin dating another, deliberately keeping both on the hook, and act all oops-gee-whiz when everything goes pear-shaped. More importantly, we don’t think the author can expect her to remain a sympathetic character the way he obviously intends.
Occasionally it’s instructive to think about fictional situations with characters swapped or reimagined, just to be sure you’re making objective judgments, and again, we don’t think a man who’s dating one woman, then starts dating another while telling the first she just has to wait around until he makes up his mind, would be labeled anything but a tremendous douche. But Tropical Disturbance is a good book anyway. When the anticipated hurricane finally comes those sequences are vivid and effective, and because Pratt has maneuvered all three members of his love triangle into the same house to weather the storm, almost anything can happen—and does. 1961 on this, with uncredited art, but which the experts say is by Robert McGinnis.
