We’ve talked often about vintage paperback art being copied. We have another example today involving Dom Lupo and Barye Phillips. Hearing those two names you’d think it was Phillips, who was a stalwart of mid-century paperback illustration, who’d been copied by Lupo, talented but lesser known. Nope—it’s the other way around. Above is Lupo’s cover for 13 French Street, which was used by Gold Medal Books in 1951. You also see here Phillips’ cover for Little Tramp (larger version here), which dates from 1957. Naughty Barry.
But Lupo copied too, sort of. He seems to have used as his inspiration a promo photo of U.S. actress Rita Gam, below. Using photos as the basis for illustrations was pretty normal, as we’ve documented before, so Lupo was just doing what artists did. You can see he changed the angle a bit, so it’s not a true copy so much as a template. There’s an internet replication error we should note: a few places say the Gam photo is from her 1952 thriller The Thief. Which means, obviously, she could not have inspired Lupo unless she had a time machine. Since the poses are so similar, we assume the attribution to The Thief is simply wrong—though ironic, because in art, everyone is a little bit of a thief. Great work by all involved.
