The cover you see above for Berkely Mather’s, aka John Evan Weston-Davies’, 1960 adventure The Pass Beyond Kashmir is one of the more pleasing we’ve come across. It’s by Barbara Walton, a preeminent dust sleeve illustrator from the 1950s until around 2000. We’ve featured her a few times, such as here, here, and here, and this effort maintains her incredibly high standard. The scene depicted makes one think there’s a major romantic subplot in the novel, but the love interest is in the book for maybe twenty pages. It isn’t Walton’s fault that the art gave us expectations that weren’t met. It happens with covers sometimes. No romantic adventure here.
The story actually revolves around a sardonic and extremely determined ex-intelligence operative named Idwal Rees who gets caught up in a search for missing documents in the Himalayas that might reveal the location of an oil discovery. The action takes the form of a quest from Bombay-Mumbai into the high mountains, with new difficulties encountered in each stop by he and partner Smedley, servant Safaraz, and reluctant informer Poison. Each obstacle is followed by desperate problem solving, and hairsbreadth escapes. The aforementioned sort-of love interest, a nurse named Claire Culverton, is mainly a source of consternation for Rees and a focus for his chauvinism.
The set-up and framework are fine, but we felt that the book got bogged down with too much local color. Obviously, authors wish to impart that they’ve at a minimum done their homework, and at a maximum lived some version of what they’re writing about, but there’s also such a thing as narrative flow. We get it—Mather was really in India and Pakistan. He even served in the army there. But in our opinion he needed another pass from an editor to make for a better book. Still, as it resolved, it was decent, though anyone of Indian, Pakistani, or Chinese descent—or of good conscience—will bristle at the treatment meted out by Rees and other Brits. But you know that going in, right?
