
Is Having Wonderful Crime a pulp style movie? It has crime in the title, so we had a look. It’s in the vein of The Thin Man and deals with a newlywed couple and their lawyer pal, amateur sleuths all, who go to a lakeside vacation resort and get mixed up in the mystery of a missing stage magician and his trunk of secrets. It’s a pleasant film but short on actual laughs. We blame the screenplay, which borrows the title of Craig Rice’s, aka Georgiana Craig’s source novel, and little else. The acting talent is definitely there to result in a good movie, but Pat O’Brien, George Murphy, and Carole Lombard can do only so much with such off-target stabs at screwball comedy.
Still, even though this flick is no Thin Man, it’s worth a watch because of its genial mood and fun cast. Lombard is charming even in a hair-do that must have inspired Francis Ford Coppola’s vision of Dracula, O’Brien and Murphy manage a few witty exchanges, and bit player Chili Williams pops up a couple of time in her famed polka dots. Are those elements enough to make you expend your valuable time? Perhaps not, but how about this? If you don’t count the credits Having Wonderful Crime is maybe sixty-five minutes long, which means you can screen it as a warm-up feature at your next movie night. It premiered today in 1945.