We like books set in carnivals. They’ve been among our most interesting reads. So we figured a movie set in a carnival—Carnival Story, with Anne Baxter and Steve Cochran—was a natural. We gave it a look and it’s an above average drama about how Baxter becomes a high diver in a Munich carnival and makes a big splash, but has relationship issues that threaten to derail her career and life. Her main problem is Cochran. He lies, he cheats, and he steals, but she just can’t quit him, even though her diving partner Lyle Bettger is totally devoted to her. Even after she marries Bettger she can’t keep her hands off Cochran. This can only end badly. And by badly we mean violence and death.
Carnival Story is one of those movies with an unspoken sexual subtext. Why would Baxter let Cochran mistreat her again and again? Well, because he gives her something no other man can. Though it couldn’t be shown onscreen we can understand that something to be sexual passion. Bettger, and later George Nader, are both devoted to Baxter, and they’re nice guys besides, but they’re square. Cochran gets Baxter’s loins all feverish. Portraying a woman trapped in this dilemma during Hollywood’s age of censorship takes acting skill, and Baxter, an Academy Award and Golden Globe winner by this point, has plenty of that. Anything she’s in is worth a watch. Carnival Story premiered today in 1954.