
Third in the Thin Man series following 1934’s The Thin Man and 1936’s After the Thin Man, the mystery caper flick Another Thin Man sees dilettante detective William Powell, who is always trying to retire, suckered by family acquaintance C. Aubrey Smith into taking another case. Smith, playing an elderly blueblood, has been receiving death threats. He thinks he knows who’s behind them—a disgruntled former employee. Powell, along with his life partner in crime solving Myrna Loy, spends the film ensconced in Smith’s elegant estate as bizarre and threatening occurrences unnerve the occupants. Of course, occurrences always offer clues, and Powell is observant as always, interspersed between the drinks he consumes.
Another Thin Man isn’t as good as the previous two films, but we can’t think of many series where the third film is the best. Do they drop off due to screenwriter ideas drying up, actors giving less to the roles, audiences becoming jaded? We can’t say. This series has so much going for it that film three taking a dip in quality doesn’t make for a bad experience. Powell and Loy still banter better than anyone, the lovely Virginia Grey does fine in her co-starring role, and the production values are of course top notch. To the latter, the entire sequence in the fictional West Indies Club is priceless.
Like his character who’s always trying to quit sleuthing, we imagine Powell and Loy were always trying to move on from this series. But popular demand is an irresistible force. Their hard-drinking, sharp-tongued lovebirds made the Thin Man movies events, and the public continued to love them even as the scripts got a little weaker and Powell got a little weirder (we can’t figure out why he filled the movie with double-takes—you’ll see what we mean). But in the end you won’t ask too many questions about this slice of sweet and effortless entertainment. Well, maybe one. You may ask why your marriage can’t be as fun as Powell’s and Loy’s. The answer may be simply to drink more. Another Thin Man premiered today in 1939.
























































































































































